Adnaan Stumo: “I Wanted to Be a Grain of Sand in the Storm”
As part of COP31, we speak with activist and captain Adnaan Stumo, who participated in the Sumud Flotilla and the Climate Justice Flotilla, about the attempt to deliver humanitarian aid to Gaza, the Israeli military’s intervention against the flotilla, experiences in detention, the ecological destruction caused by militarism, and the connections between the Palestinian struggle and climate justice.
Özdeş Özbay: Okay, today we are together with Adnaan Stumo. He's an activist and a captain. He joined the Sumud Flotilla first, and then he joined the Climate Justice Flotilla while they were sailing to Santa Marta and back to Europe and other countries. So, Adnaan, could you please tell us why you joined the Sumud Flotilla?
Adnaan Stumo: Thanks so much for having me. First of all, I joined the Sumud Flotilla because I was working in Palestine at the time they were setting it up. I was building youth centers, teaching kids MMA, boxing, jiu-jitsu and stuff, and doing some other kinds of land defense.
Ö.Ö.: When was that?
A.S.: This was last summer.
Ö.Ö.: During the genocide, you were there?
A.S.: I was in the West Bank, and I was inside '48, in the southern desert, in the Naqab. I was actually there during the 12-Day War in June, when Israel and the US attacked Iran.
But my training is really as a maritime professional, and I have a captain's license. I got a call from my brother, who was also on the flotilla. They were really desperate because they had thousands and thousands of people who wanted to join, but they didn't have enough captains. In order to make a sea journey like that, it can be quite dangerous if you don't have people who are decently qualified and can handle the safety and technical aspects.
So I actually left Palestine early, knowing that I probably would never be able to come back. I flew to Barcelona, and we had an amazing team. We fixed up dozens and dozens of boats. We ended up arriving with 42 boats, I believe, but we had close to 70 at one point. With all the boats that got bombed along the way and other technical problems, some people dropped out.
Ö.Ö.: Even beginning from Tunisia, right?
A.S.: Yeah, in Tunisia, we got firebombed twice. I was anchored right between the two boats that were firebombed.
But that's why I joined. I feel that we all have different skills in this movement. You're in media. I happen to be good at maritime actions, and that's what I'm trained for. So I decided that was where I could be most useful, fulfill my part, be a grain of sand in a sandstorm.
Ö.Ö.: Of course, Israel was quite brutal to activists as well. All the Sumud Flotilla activists were captured by the Israeli army, and you were one of them too.
A.S.: That's correct.
Ö.Ö.: And so, how was your experience there?
A.S.: Well, first, they intercepted us, I want to say, about 75 miles off the coast of occupied Palestine. They came first with speedboats, speeding around us in circles, making big waves for the small sailboats, and then shining spotlights and pointing lasers at us from their rifles.
Then they hit my boat in particular, and many of the boats, with a high-powered water cannon, like firefighters use to put out big building fires. And when that hits you, man, it's like getting punched.
The first time it hit me, I didn't realize that I had to duck my head. It hit me in the back of the head, and I was steering the big wheel of the boat. It slammed my head forward into the wheel and knocked me out for a second.
I woke up again, and then I saw my friend get hit and thrown. He's not a small guy. He's maybe 70 or 80 kilos, and he got thrown all the way across the boat by that.
Then they were yelling at us through a speaker, "Stop the boat! Stop the engines!" I was refusing, obviously, but they sprayed us for over an hour with that. Even when they stop, you're shivering cold from all that seawater.
My crew started getting beaten up. I had a couple of small women on board who were getting really hurt by the water cannon. So after over an hour, I cut the engines.
Then they came on board with a special forces team. You see the green laser dot on your chest from the rifle. There's an 18-year-old behind that trigger who's trained to think of you as an enemy who wants to murder all Jews.
And it's completely ridiculous when you have so many Jewish people on board, so many people from all over. We had people from over 80 nations on board the flotilla, and we had baby formula and critical supplies for the starving people of Gaza.
When we got taken to the prison, my brother refused to give up his passport. He said, "I want to speak to a lawyer," and they punched him in the face. Right in front of me, they knocked him down, and four guards were kicking him while he was trying to protect himself, handcuffed on the ground.
Ö.Ö.: Yeah.
A.S.: I personally wasn't beaten up too badly, just minor stuff. But they definitely went after the Turkish and North African activists, Tunisians, Moroccans and Algerians, much harder than the white folks. It was not pretty.
Ö.Ö.: And what did they do to the Jewish activists?
A.S.: The Jewish activists were quite full of righteous anger at this state, which claims to represent them and which is actually making Jews around the whole world much less safe by pretending to represent Jews and committing such atrocities in their name.
They were quite ferocious, actually, standing up and yelling at the guards, saying, "Shame on you! How dare you?"
But they had an extra level of protection because of their identity. I didn't see them being handled or treated very harshly, certainly compared to the Muslim activists and others.
Ö.Ö.: Yeah, because that would be weird, though, because Israel accuses anti-Zionist Jews of being self-hating Jews. And sometimes the Israeli government doesn't allow them to enter Israel.
A.S.: Sometimes, especially with high-profile folks. But a lot of the leaders of some of the protective presence movements in the West Bank are Jewish.
I'm banned now. So many people who are doing protective presence have been banned. But if, for example, you get your Israeli passport as a Jewish person through the whole right-of-return bullshit, excuse my language, then you're actually able to stay and do long-term work, push the limits a bit more and use your specific levels of privilege for that.
I personally know a number of Jewish folks who have been banned, like Norman Finkelstein and Miko Peled.
Ö.Ö.: Yeah.
A.S.: But at the end of the day, it's all about what you can get away with.
One of the reasons we weren't more brutalized on the flotilla in general was because there was so much media attention on us. When it comes to confronting power, they will do everything to you that they think they can get away with.
But it's harder. They're much more worried about a headline saying "Israel brutalizes Jewish protesters" than one about someone from Tunisia. The press doesn't care as much, and much less about Palestinians.
That's why it's not that they respect the internationals more than Palestinians. They'd like to kill all of us.
Ö.Ö.: Yeah.
A.S.: But they know that they can't get away with as much. So it's only a question of what we can force. How far can we go? And how far will they go?
They're worried about the backlash in the press. So we have some level of protection from that, but we're always making a calculation, and they're always making a calculation.
How far can we go in terms of putting our bodies on the line without subjecting our members to rape and murder? Many people were sexually assaulted, especially in the second flotilla.
Ö.Ö.: Yeah.
A.S.: And they're always making a calculation. How far can we go to make the people who are trying to confront this occupation and this genocide so traumatized that they'll never come back?
But they also want to do it in a secret way so that they don't get a New York Times front page saying, "They shot 500 activists in the head."
So we're always in this weird dance, and it very much depends on how much media, government or international attention you can get.
Ö.Ö.: You're actually Lebanese-American, which means that you're an American citizen.
A.S.: I am a US citizen, not a Lebanese citizen, because my mother's side is Lebanese, and you don't get citizenship unless it's through your father's side.
Ö.Ö.: Did you get any help from the United States government? How were you treated back in the USA? Did being an American citizen help you a little bit, maybe in comparison to other activists, regarding the reactions of the Israeli army?
A.S.: It's actually very ironic because the people who got out the earliest were the people whose governments, by and large, either don't recognize Israel or are quite confrontational with Israel.
There was a massive Malaysian contingent, and their government sent a charter plane. I think they were only in prison for two or three days. I guess it was a commercial plane, but they were basically all taken away quite quickly.
Also, the folks who went to Türkiye got out at least a few days before us.
It was the Americans, the British, the Germans, and maybe a couple of others, Norwegians or Finns, who were in the longest.
We were in the longest because our consulate officials, whom we met with after a few days, were like, "Sorry, there's nothing we can do."
These are the governments that send the most money and the most military equipment to the terrorist state of Israel, and they pretend they have absolutely no power at all.
Basically, the subtext was, "We consider you problematic. Maybe you're dissidents or terrorists, and we have no desire to help you."
It was actually the most powerful governments in the world, which are also the friendliest with Israel, that did the least.
We were all on hunger strike too, so we didn't eat for a week. By the time the IOF decided to basically put us on buses and send us across the border to Jordan, we were kind of collapsing after a week with no food.
But being an American citizen definitely protected me a hundred times more than if I were Palestinian or even Palestinian-American. Dozens of Palestinian-Americans have been killed and had their land seized in the West Bank and elsewhere.
Not what you might expect of the world's superpower.
Ö.Ö.: Okay. After the Sumud Flotilla, you joined another flotilla, the Climate Justice Flotilla. So how did you end up there?
Some folks believe that there's no direct relationship between climate change and what's going on in Gaza. But actually, all around the world, climate activists are making that connection.
Even just a few days ago, here at the People's March, almost all sections of the demonstration had slogans about free Palestine and climate justice at the same time.
So why did you join the Climate Justice Flotilla?
A.S.: The direct answer is that there were a lot of people I became quite close with in the Global Sumud Flotilla who were running the Climate Justice Flotilla. They asked me to join, and I accepted.
But on a broader scale, of course, militarism is probably one of the greatest polluters of our day. I mean, the ecocide that has been committed in Gaza.
I have a comrade, Dr. Ammar Nashabi, in Lebanon, who's done serious, in-depth work on this and the recovery of the land, the heavy metals, and the impact of all the heavy equipment and tanks compacting the earth.
When it rains, the floods rise because there's nowhere for the water to drain into the ground. The ground has been compressed by thousands of tons of bombs, equipment and collapsing buildings that have fallen on it.
It is intimately connected.
At the end of the day, my view is that we do ourselves such a disservice by focusing on this movementism, on this fragmentation where I'm working on this aspect and you're working on that aspect.
Of course, as individuals and as movements, we have to find where we fit in and where we can do the most good. But it all comes back to an all-consuming machine of military-industrial-imperial capitalism.
Capitalism has to always grow. It has to grow exponentially. Every country, every economy has to grow by at least 3% or more per year in order to sustain itself. If it's flat, it's a recession, and it collapses.
The investors, the billionaires who put their money into the market, have to receive a return on that money because they can't be bothered to work. That's the way they've managed to dominate and own the world and all of us.
If they don't get a return, they don't invest their money, and the whole system goes down.
It all comes down to this insatiable, all-consuming system. It's a fire and an acid that no regulatory framework can contain because, at the end of the day, the people with the most money can buy out all the politicians too.
Ö.Ö.: Yeah.
A.S.: So I think they're both two branches of the same rotting tree. And by confronting one, we confront the other.
We shouldn't, at the end of the day, in my view, get too focused on the branches. We need to aim right at the base of the trunk and confront the root cause.
Ö.Ö.: Okay, Adnaan, thank you so much for being with us today. I hope to see you again and talk to you again.
A.S.: I really appreciate you having me.